ELSS vs. NPS: Which mutual fund for tax saving and better returns?
View as Visual Story
The tax-filing season often feels like a mad dash, doesn’t it? Every year, around January or February, my phone starts buzzing with calls from folks like Anita in Chennai, earning ₹1.2 lakh a month, or Vikram in Hyderabad, just starting out at ₹65,000. Their question is almost always the same: "Deepak, I need to save tax under 80C. Should I go with ELSS or NPS? Which one gives better returns?"
It’s a classic dilemma, and frankly, a fantastic question. Both ELSS (Equity-Linked Savings Schemes) and NPS (National Pension System) are popular options for salaried professionals in India looking to trim their tax bill, but they’re built for very different purposes. Comparing them side-by-side isn't just about finding the bigger tax break; it's about understanding which one truly aligns with your financial goals, liquidity needs, and risk appetite. Let’s dive deep into the world of ELSS vs. NPS and figure out which is your better bet for tax saving and potentially better returns.
ELSS vs. NPS: Unpacking the Fundamentals
Before we pick a winner, let’s quickly understand what each of these really is, beyond just a tax-saving instrument.
What is ELSS?
ELSS is basically a diversified equity mutual fund. Think of it as investing directly into the stock market, but managed by professional fund managers. The "Equity-Linked" part means a significant portion (at least 80% as per SEBI regulations) of your money is invested in company stocks. The "Savings Scheme" part is where the tax benefit comes in – investments up to ₹1.5 lakh per financial year are eligible for deduction under Section 80C.
The biggest highlight? A mandatory lock-in period of just 3 years. This is the shortest lock-in among all Section 80C options, making it quite attractive for those who want their money back sooner rather than later.
What is NPS?
The National Pension System, on the other hand, is a government-backed, long-term retirement savings scheme. It's designed specifically to provide you with a regular income post-retirement. You can invest in different asset classes – Equity (E), Corporate Bonds (C), Government Securities (G), and even Alternative Assets (A) – and choose your allocation based on your risk profile.
NPS also offers tax benefits under Section 80C (up to ₹1.5 lakh) for your contribution. But here’s the kicker: it also offers an additional tax deduction of up to ₹50,000 under Section 80CCD(1B), over and above the 80C limit. This is a significant advantage for those looking to save even more tax.
The catch? NPS is primarily a retirement product, which means your money is locked in until you turn 60. We’ll get into the implications of that next.
Lock-in, Liquidity & Control: The Real ELSS vs. NPS Showdown
This is where the rubber truly meets the road. Many people, especially young professionals, often overlook the lock-in periods, only to regret it later. I’ve seen this countless times.
ELSS: The Flexibility Champion
With ELSS, your money is locked in for just three years. Once those three years are up, you have complete control. You can redeem your units, stay invested, or switch to another fund. This flexibility is a huge plus. Imagine Priya in Pune, who started investing in ELSS at 30. By 33, her investments were free to be redeemed. This meant she could potentially use those funds for a house down payment at 35, or her child’s education later, if needed, without any severe penalties.
The short lock-in makes ELSS a great choice for those who want their tax-saving investments to also serve as a potential medium-term growth vehicle, not just a retirement fund.
NPS: The Retirement Workhorse
NPS, being a pension product, mandates that your money stays invested until you reach 60 years of age (for Tier I accounts). There are provisions for partial withdrawals for specific reasons like children's higher education, marriage, or critical illness, but these are subject to strict conditions and limits (up to 25% of your own contribution, max three times during the entire tenure, with a gap of 5 years).
And here's a crucial point many miss: at maturity (age 60), you can withdraw a maximum of 60% of your corpus as a tax-free lump sum. The remaining 40% (at least) *must* be used to purchase an annuity (a regular pension) from a life insurance company. That annuity income is then taxable as per your slab rate.
Honestly, most advisors won't tell you this directly, but this mandatory annuitization of 40% (or more) significantly limits your control over your entire corpus. My friend Rahul in Bengaluru, who started NPS early, expressed frustration when he realized he couldn’t access all his funds to start a business in his late 40s. He wished he'd diversified more into ELSS earlier for that much-needed flexibility.
The Returns Game: Where Do You Stand a Better Chance?
When it comes to "better returns," we're usually talking about wealth creation. Let's pit ELSS and NPS against each other on this front.
ELSS: Pure Equity, Higher Potential
Since ELSS funds are predominantly equity-oriented, they carry the inherent volatility of the stock market. However, over the long term (say, 5-7 years and beyond), equity markets have historically delivered superior returns compared to other asset classes. Looking at AMFI data, well-managed ELSS funds have often mirrored or even outperformed broader market indices like the Nifty 50 or SENSEX over a decade, with some funds delivering average CAGRs (Compounded Annual Growth Rates) in the range of 12-15% or even more in good market cycles.
The fund manager's expertise plays a crucial role here. They actively manage your portfolio, aiming to generate alpha (returns above the benchmark). Because you have direct equity exposure, the potential for significant wealth creation is higher, especially if you pick a good fund and stay invested beyond the 3-year lock-in.
NPS: Balanced Approach, Moderate Potential
NPS offers you choices for asset allocation: Equity (E), Corporate Bonds (C), Government Securities (G), and Alternative Assets (A). If you choose the "Active Choice," you can decide your allocation, though there are caps on equity exposure (e.g., up to 75% for younger investors, tapering down as you age). If you choose "Auto Choice," your allocation is dynamically managed based on your age.
While NPS does offer equity exposure, it’s rarely 100% equity for extended periods, especially with the auto-choice option which becomes more conservative as you age. This blended approach typically leads to lower volatility but also potentially lower overall returns compared to a pure equity fund like ELSS, especially in a bull market. The aim of NPS isn't aggressive wealth creation, but rather stable, moderate growth to build a retirement corpus with reduced risk.
Here’s what I’ve seen work for busy professionals like Vikram in Hyderabad: a combination. He puts his 80CCD(1B) amount into NPS for the extra tax benefit and then channels a good chunk of his 80C into ELSS for higher growth potential and liquidity post-3 years. It’s about leveraging the strengths of both.
Tax Benefits and Exit Taxation: The Fine Print You Can't Ignore
Both ELSS and NPS shine in tax saving, but their taxation at maturity or withdrawal differs significantly.
Tax Benefits with ELSS
- Investment: Up to ₹1.5 lakh under Section 80C.
- Returns: Long Term Capital Gains (LTCG) tax of 10% on gains exceeding ₹1 lakh in a financial year. For instance, if you make a profit of ₹2.5 lakh from ELSS in a year, the first ₹1 lakh is tax-free, and the remaining ₹1.5 lakh will be taxed at 10% (i.e., ₹15,000).
- Dividends: If an ELSS fund declares dividends, they are added to your income and taxed as per your slab rate.
Tax Benefits with NPS
- Investment: Up to ₹1.5 lakh under Section 80C (Tier I). Additional deduction of up to ₹50,000 under Section 80CCD(1B) (Tier I) – this is a big draw! Employer contribution (Tier I) up to 10% of basic + DA is also tax-deductible under Section 80CCD(2).
- Returns: The corpus accumulated is tax-exempt.
- Withdrawal at 60: Up to 60% of the corpus can be withdrawn as a tax-free lump sum. The remaining minimum 40% (or more, if you choose) must be used to purchase an annuity.
- Annuity Income: The pension income you receive from the annuity is fully taxable as per your income tax slab.
So, while NPS offers a substantial additional tax deduction during the investment phase, its taxation during the withdrawal phase, especially the annuity part, can be a dampener for some. ELSS, on the other hand, has a simpler LTCG tax structure, giving you more control over how and when you pay tax (you can defer by not redeeming).
Common Mistakes People Make When Choosing Between ELSS and NPS
It's easy to get lost in the jargon, so let me highlight some pitfalls I see frequently:
- Focusing Only on 80C: Many jump into an investment just to save the ₹1.5 lakh under 80C. While NPS offers that, its extra ₹50,000 under 80CCD(1B) is often overlooked. If your primary goal is maximum tax saving *today*, NPS clearly wins on that front.
- Ignoring the Lock-in & Liquidity: This is probably the biggest mistake. People forget that NPS funds are locked until 60. Anita in Chennai almost put all her eggs in the NPS basket for tax saving, only to realize she’d need some liquidity in 15 years for her child’s overseas education. For such goals, ELSS, with its 3-year lock-in, would have been a far better choice. Always match the investment's liquidity with your future needs.
- Not Understanding the Annuity Clause of NPS: "Oh, I get my money at 60!" That’s what many think. They don’t realize 40% *must* go into an annuity, and that annuity income is taxable. This significantly impacts your post-retirement financial planning.
- Treating ELSS as Just a Tax Product: ELSS is a mutual fund first, a tax-saver second. Its potential lies in equity market growth. Redeeming immediately after 3 years might not always be optimal; letting good funds compound over 5-10+ years can create substantial wealth.
- Not Aligning with Financial Goals: ELSS is great for medium-term goals (say, 5-10 years) alongside tax saving. NPS is purely for long-term retirement planning. Don't use a retirement product for a mid-life goal.
Frequently Asked Questions About ELSS and NPS
1. Can I invest in both ELSS and NPS?
Absolutely! In fact, for many salaried professionals, a combination of both makes the most sense. You can claim the full ₹1.5 lakh under 80C through ELSS (or a mix of ELSS and other 80C options) and then invest an additional ₹50,000 in NPS under 80CCD(1B) for extra tax savings. This way, you get the best of both worlds – liquidity and growth from ELSS, and additional tax benefits and retirement planning from NPS.
2. Which is better for a young professional (e.g., 25-year-old) starting their career?
For a 25-year-old with a long investing horizon, ELSS offers the potential for aggressive equity growth and builds financial discipline with its 3-year lock-in. It also maintains flexibility for future life goals. However, starting a small NPS contribution early (especially to utilize the 80CCD(1B) benefit) is also smart for building a strong retirement base, provided you understand the long lock-in and annuity part. A balanced approach with a higher allocation to ELSS initially might be ideal.
3. What if I need my money before 60 from NPS?
As mentioned, Tier I NPS is largely locked in until age 60. You can make partial withdrawals for specific life events (child's education/marriage, buying a house, critical illness), up to 25% of your *own* contributions, with specific conditions. Early exit before 60 is also possible, but it means you can only withdraw 20% as a lump sum, and 80% *must* be annuitized, which isn't ideal.
4. Is ELSS guaranteed to give high returns?
No, like all equity mutual funds, ELSS investments are subject to market risks. There are no guaranteed returns. The "better returns" potential comes from its equity exposure over the long term, which historically tends to beat inflation and other asset classes. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
5. How do I choose a good ELSS fund?
When picking an ELSS fund, look for a consistent track record (over 5-7 years), a fund manager with experience, a diversified portfolio, and a reasonable expense ratio. Don't just chase last year's top performer. You can research funds on the AMFI website or consult a SEBI-registered financial advisor.
My Take: It’s Not About Either/Or, But How You Mix It!
Ultimately, the choice between ELSS and NPS isn't about one being universally "better" than the other. It’s about understanding your current financial situation, your goals for the next 5, 10, 20, and 30 years, and your comfort with liquidity and risk. For most salaried professionals, especially those in their 20s and 30s, I often suggest a combination:
- Utilize NPS for the additional ₹50,000 tax benefit under 80CCD(1B) to kickstart your retirement corpus.
- For the rest of your 80C investment, lean heavily on ELSS. Its short lock-in and pure equity exposure offer flexibility and higher growth potential for various life goals beyond just retirement.
Don't just invest for tax saving; invest for wealth creation and financial freedom. If you're wondering how much you need to invest monthly to hit your goals, check out our Goal SIP Calculator. It’s a handy tool I often recommend to visualize your investment journey.
Keep investing smart, keep learning, and your financial future will thank you!
Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Please read all scheme-related documents carefully. This article is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice. Consult a SEBI-registered financial advisor for personalized guidance.